Opening hours
Opening hours not available
We don’t have confirmed opening hours for Commander Cody's yet. Call (631) 749-1851 to check before you go.
Typical hours for restaurants in New York
Most restaurants in New York open around 11:00 AM and close around 10:00 PM on weekdays; 84% are open on Sundays and 61% stay open until 10 PM or later.
Based on 708 similar places in our guide.
Location & directions
41 Smith StreetShelter Island, NY 11964
About Commander Cody's
Commander Cody's is a restaurant you'll find at 41 Smith Street in Shelter Island, New York. It is one of 6 places to eat and drink we list in Shelter Island.
You can visit for dine-in.
You can reach the team at (631) 749-1851.
Quick facts
- Category
- Restaurant
- Address
- 41 Smith Street, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Phone
- (631) 749-1851
- Listing updated
- · Suggest an edit
Popular times (typical for restaurants)
Restaurants are usually busiest around 6 PM on Fridays; one of the quieter times is around 3 PM on weekdays.
Based on typical visit patterns and the usual opening hours of restaurants in New York.
Typical prices for restaurants in New York
Based on 253 menus with 13,823 priced items from restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $14.00, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $20.00.
We don’t have Commander Cody's’s own menu on file yet, so use these figures as a guide to what restaurants in New York typically charge.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Caesar Salad | 20% | $12.00 |
| French Fries | 14% | $6.00 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | 12% | $10.00 |
| Onion Rings | 12% | $7.95 |
| Sweet Potato Fries | 11% | $8.00 |
| House Salad | 9% | $9.00 |
| Shrimp Cocktail | 9% | $16.50 |
| Wings | 9% | $15.00 |
Calculated from 253 menus in our guide. Prices vary by location and change over time.
Features & amenities
Service options
- Dine-in
The neighborhood
Within a 10-minute walk (half a mile) of Commander Cody's there are 2 other places to eat and drink in our guide, and 4 within one mile. By type, the places within a mile include American (1) and Pizza (1).
Competition is light: 2 other restaurants are within a mile and 9 within three miles. The closest is Vine Street Cafe, 0.8 mi away.
Nearest places of other kinds
- American18 Bay0.3 mi
- PizzaBella Vita Pizza0.4 mi
- ItalianSweet Tomato's1.5 mi
- SeafoodAnker2.8 mi
- Cafes & CoffeeBruce's Cheese Emporium & Cafe2.8 mi
What to expect at a restaurant
General restaurants are places that do not fit neatly into a single cuisine: family restaurants, grills, bistros, eclectic kitchens and multi-cuisine menus. They are often local favorites that serve a bit of everything, from breakfast plates to steaks and seafood.
What to order
- House specialties – what regulars come back for
- Daily specials – often the freshest dishes
- Local dishes – anything named after the town or region
Good to know
- Check the latest hours before you go – independent restaurants change them more often.
- Weekend evenings are usually the busiest time.
- Tipping 18–20% on table service is standard in the US.
Reviews
Write a reviewNo visitor reviews yet. Been to Commander Cody's? Share your experience to help other diners.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Commander Cody's located?
Commander Cody's is located at 41 Smith Street, Shelter Island, NY 11964.
What is the phone number of Commander Cody's?
You can call Commander Cody's at (631) 749-1851.
Does Commander Cody's offer delivery or takeout?
Delivery is not listed for Commander Cody's. Listed service options: dine-in.
What else is near Commander Cody's?
There are 4 other places to eat and drink within a mile of Commander Cody's. Nearby options include 18 Bay (0.3 mi), Bella Vita Pizza (0.4 mi), and Sweet Tomato's (1.5 mi).
Are there other restaurants near Commander Cody's?
2 other restaurants within a mile. The closest is Vine Street Cafe, 0.8 mi away.
How much do restaurants in New York cost?
Based on 253 menus with 13,823 priced items from restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $14.00, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $20.00.
Nearby places
All in Shelter Island
Listing data © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Details may have changed – please verify with the business.